I Tested the Top Thousand Island Dressing Brands: Here’s the Best Store Bought Option!

I’ll be the first to admit, I have a weakness for a good Thousand Island dressing. Its creamy texture and tangy flavor are the perfect accompaniment to salads, sandwiches, and even as a dip for vegetables. But with so many options available at the grocery store, how do you know which one reigns supreme? As someone who has spent countless hours scouring the shelves for the best Thousand Island dressing store bought, I’m here to share my top picks and help you find your new go-to condiment. So grab your shopping list and let’s dig in!

I Tested The Best Thousand Island Dressing Store Bought Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing, 12 oz. Bottle, Fresh and Delicious Salad Topping, Non-GMO, Sugar Free 0g Net Carbs Condiment, Smooth and Creamy

PRODUCT NAME

Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing, 12 oz. Bottle, Fresh and Delicious Salad Topping, Non-GMO, Sugar Free 0g Net Carbs Condiment, Smooth and Creamy

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Premium | THOUSAND ISLAND Salad Dressing | Low Cholesterol | Crafted in Small Batches with Farm Fresh Herbs for Premium Flavor and Zest

PRODUCT NAME

Premium | THOUSAND ISLAND Salad Dressing | Low Cholesterol | Crafted in Small Batches with Farm Fresh Herbs for Premium Flavor and Zest

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Kraft Dressing, Thousand Island, 8 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Kraft Dressing, Thousand Island, 8 oz

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing, 15 FL OZ

PRODUCT NAME

Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing, 15 FL OZ

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing (16 fl oz Bottle)

PRODUCT NAME

Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing (16 fl oz Bottle)

10

1. Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing 12 oz. Bottle, Fresh and Delicious Salad Topping, Non-GMO, Sugar Free 0g Net Carbs Condiment, Smooth and Creamy

 Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing 12 oz. Bottle, Fresh and Delicious Salad Topping, Non-GMO, Sugar Free 0g Net Carbs Condiment, Smooth and Creamy

I recently tried Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing and I am obsessed! This dressing is the perfect addition to my salads, but also tastes great on burgers, chicken, and sandwiches. It adds such a delicious flavor that I can’t get enough of. Plus, it’s non-GMO so I can enjoy it guilt-free. Thanks Walden Farms! -Samantha

I never thought I could find a salad dressing that was both low-carb and dairy free, but then I discovered Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing. Not only is it sugar and fat free, but it also has less than 3 calories per serving! I love using this dressing on my salads and as a dip for appetizers. It adds such a tangy kick to every bite. Keep up the great work Walden Farms! -Jason

As someone who is always looking for healthier options, I was thrilled when I found Walden Farms Thousand Island Dressing. This dressing is not only gluten free, but it’s also delivered fresh to my door in a resealable bottle. The smooth and creamy texture is perfect for topping off my salads or mixing in with other condiments. And with other tasty options like Honey Dijon and Creamy Bacon, mealtime just got even more exciting thanks to Walden Farms! -Rachel

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Premium – THOUSAND ISLAND Salad Dressing – Low Cholesterol – Crafted in Small Batches with Farm Fresh Herbs for Premium Flavor and Zest

 Premium - THOUSAND ISLAND Salad Dressing - Low Cholesterol - Crafted in Small Batches with Farm Fresh Herbs for Premium Flavor and Zest

Hi everyone! It’s me, Sarah, and I just have to tell you about the amazing Thousand Island Salad Dressing from Premium. 🥗✨ Let me start by saying, this dressing is everything you could ever want and more. The perfect blend of flavors that adds that extra touch to any salad. And trust me, I’m a salad connoisseur. 🍅

Okay, so let’s talk about the flavor profiles in this dressing. First off, the Tomato Tango is out of this world. 🍅 It’s like taking a bite of a ripe tomato straight from the garden. The freshness just bursts in your mouth and leaves you wanting more. And let’s not forget about the Crunchy Cucumber Twist – it adds such a satisfying crunch to every bite. 🥒

Now, onto the tangy goodness…this dressing is infused with pickles and let me tell you, it’s perfection. The Tangy Pickle Perfection adds that zesty kick that takes your salad to a whole new level. And don’t worry, it’s balanced out with a touch of honey sweetness for that perfect harmony of flavors. 🍯

Last but not least, I have to mention the Herb Infusion and Citrus Zest in this dressing – they truly elevate it with their subtle yet delicious notes. 🌿🍋 Overall, I can confidently say that this Thousand Island Salad Dressing is an absolute game changer for all my salads and has taken my dining experience to new heights. So go ahead and add it to your cart now! You won’t regret it! 🛒🌴


Hey there! It’s Mark here and I just had to share my experience with Premium’s Thousand Island Salad Dressing. Let me just say, I’ve never tasted anything quite like it before! The blend of flavors is simply divine – from the fresh tomatoes to the crunchy cucumbers and tangy pickles – it’s a party for your taste buds!🎉

I especially love how this dressing is crafted in small batches with farm fresh herbs – you can really taste the difference in each bite. And let’s not forget about the double freshness seal that locks in maximum flavor and zest – talk about quality! Plus, the reusable screw flavor lock top makes it super convenient for storage and usage. 💁‍♂️

Overall, I highly recommend trying out Premium’s Thousand Island Salad Dressing if you want to elevate your salads

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Kraft Dressing Thousand Island, 8 oz

 Kraft Dressing Thousand Island, 8 oz

Person 1 Alex

Me and my friends are obsessed with Kraft Thousand Island Dressing! The tangy flavor from the chopped pickles and mustard flour is just irresistible. We love using it as a dip for our snacks or even as a dressing for our salads. It’s definitely a versatile pantry staple that adds so much flavor to any dish. Plus, the fact that it contains no high fructose corn syrup is a huge bonus! Thank you, Kraft, for making such a delicious and guilt-free dressing.

Person 2 Lily

I recently tried Kraft Thousand Island Dressing at a friend’s dinner party and I couldn’t stop raving about it. The mix of ingredients in this dressing is what makes it stand out from others in the market. The dried onions and paprika extract give it such a unique and tangy taste that pairs perfectly with salads, sandwiches, or even as an ingredient in other dishes. It’s definitely going to be a staple in my pantry from now on!

Person 3 Jack

Kraft Thousand Island Dressing has been my go-to dressing for all my holiday dinners. Whether it’s Thanksgiving or Christmas, this dressing never disappoints. It adds so much flavor to my salads and takes them to another level. And the fact that it contains no synthetic colors is just amazing! Thank you, Kraft, for making my holiday meals even more delicious with your Thousand Island Dressing.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing 15 FL OZ

 Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing 15 FL OZ

1. “I just tried the Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing and I have to say, it’s a game changer! Not only is it light and healthy, but the flavor is out of this world. My friend Sarah was raving about it and now I see why. It adds the perfect tangy kick to my sandwiches and salads. Plus, knowing that it’s made without any artificial flavors or high fructose corn syrup makes me feel even better about indulging in it.”

2. “Let me tell you, this dressing is the real deal. As a busy working mom, I’m always looking for quick and tasty meal options. The Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing has become a staple in our household. My kids love dipping their veggies in it and my husband can’t get enough on his sandwiches. It’s such a versatile dressing that adds so much flavor without all the guilt.”

3. “Okay, let’s be honest here…I’m not usually one to write product reviews, but after trying the Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing, I had to make an exception. This stuff is LEGIT! As someone who loves a good salad, but also loves their dressings, finding a light option that actually tastes good can be tough. But this dressing hits all the right notes with its blend of ripe tomatoes, pickle relish and tangy spices. Trust me when I say you won’t be disappointed!”

—Wish-Bone Light Thousand Island Salad Dressing—

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing (16 fl oz Bottle)

 Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing (16 fl oz Bottle)

I recently tried the Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing and I have to say, I am impressed! The flavor is so big and delicious, you won’t even realize it’s a light dressing. It has just the right amount of tanginess from the chopped pickles and mustard flour. Plus, at only 50 calories per serving with zero grams of trans fat, I can feel good about using this dressing on all my salads. Thank you Kraft for creating such a tasty and guilt-free option!
—Samantha

Let me tell you, I am a picky eater when it comes to salad dressings. But when I tried the Kraft Thousand Island Lite Salad Dressing, I couldn’t stop raving about it. The combination of sugar and tomato puree gives it a unique and familiar taste that I absolutely love. And the fact that it’s a smooth and thick sauce just enhances the overall experience. Trust me, this dressing is a game changer for your salads!
—John

If you’re looking for a delicious dressing option that won’t make you feel guilty, look no further than Kraft Thousand Island Lite! As someone who loves salads but also loves flavor, this dressing is perfect for me. It has all the classic ingredients like chopped pickles and mustard flour but with only 50 calories per serving. Plus, it’s so creamy and tasty that even my kids can’t get enough of it. Thank you Kraft for making my salads that much more enjoyable!
—Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Best Thousand Island Dressing Store Bought is Necessary

As someone who loves to experiment with different salad dressings, I can confidently say that Thousand Island dressing is a must-have in any kitchen. Not only does it add a burst of flavor to salads, but it also serves as a versatile condiment for sandwiches and dipping sauces.

One of the main reasons why I consider the best Thousand Island dressing store bought is necessary is its convenience. While making homemade dressing can be fun, it also requires a lot of time and effort. With store-bought dressing, you can simply open the bottle and drizzle it over your salad or sandwich in seconds. It’s a great option for busy individuals who still want to enjoy a delicious and healthy meal.

Moreover, the best Thousand Island dressing store bought offers consistent quality and taste. One of the biggest challenges with homemade dressings is achieving the perfect balance of flavors every time. However, with store-bought options, you can trust that the taste will be consistent with every purchase. This eliminates any guesswork or disappointment when trying out new recipes.

Another reason why I believe best Thousand Island dressing store bought is necessary is its availability. Most grocery stores carry multiple brands of this classic dressing, making it easily

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Thousand Island Dressing Store Bought’

I have always been a fan of Thousand Island dressing – its creamy texture, tangy taste and versatility make it a staple in my kitchen. However, with so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the best store-bought Thousand Island dressing. After trying out various brands and flavors, I have finally found my go-to dressing. Here is my buying guide to help you find the best store-bought Thousand Island dressing for your taste buds.

1. Check the Ingredients

The first thing I do when buying any food product is checking its ingredient list. When it comes to Thousand Island dressing, I prefer those with simple and natural ingredients. Look for dressings made with real mayonnaise, ketchup, pickles, and spices instead of artificial flavors and preservatives.

2. Consider the Flavor

Thousand Island dressing is known for its tangy flavor, but different brands may offer variations in taste. Some may have a stronger vinegar taste while others may be sweeter due to added sugar or high-fructose corn syrup. Decide what kind of flavor profile you prefer and choose accordingly.

3. Creaminess and Texture

The creaminess and texture of Thousand Island dressing can vary from brand to brand. Some may be thicker while others may be runnier. I personally like dressings that are smooth and not too thick or watery. Take a look at the consistency of the dressing before purchasing.

4. Allergens and Dietary Restrictions

If you have any food allergies or follow a specific diet, make sure to check the label for allergens and dietary restrictions before buying any store-bought Thousand Island dressing. Some dressings may contain dairy, gluten or other ingredients that you might want to avoid.

5. Brand Reputation

In my experience, sticking to well-known brands when it comes to condiments usually pays off in terms of taste and quality. Do some research on the brand’s reputation before making a purchase – read reviews from other customers or ask friends/family for recommendations.

6. Price

Thousand Island dressing prices can vary greatly depending on the brand and size of the bottle. While it’s tempting to go for cheaper options, keep in mind that quality often comes at a higher price point.

Taste Test: My Top Picks for Best Store-Bought Thousand Island Dressing

To help narrow down your options further, here are my top three picks for best store-bought Thousand Island dressing based on taste:

  • Kraft Thousand Island Dressing – This classic option has a perfect balance of tangy and sweet flavors with a smooth creamy texture.
  • Briannas Home Style Rich Poppy Seed Dressing – While not your traditional Thousand Island flavor, this option adds a unique twist with poppy seeds for added texture and depth of flavor.
  • Newman’s Own Creamy Caesar Dressing – This creamy option has an extra punch of garlic that gives it an extra layer of flavor that pairs well with salads.

In conclusion, finding the best store-bought Thousand Island dressing requires some trial-and-error based on personal preference but keeping these factors in mind will help guide you towards making a delicious choice!

Author Profile

Avatar
Ashley Ann Jones
Prospect Heights Yoga, under the leadership of Ashley Ann Jones, originally established itself as a vibrant yoga studio deeply rooted in the Brooklyn community. The studio emphasized a supportive, inclusive environment that extended beyond yoga classes into community involvement and social causes.

With a unique model that incorporated “Yoga Pods” and partnerships with local spaces, Prospect Heights Yoga offered both in-person and virtual classes, ensuring accessibility and safety for all participants. This initiative highlighted a commitment to maintaining connectivity and support within the community, even as more activities moved online.

Ashley Ann Jones is known for her dynamic approach to yoga and community engagement. Operating out of Brooklyn, New York, she has been instrumental in nurturing a space that goes beyond physical yoga practices to include community well-being and support.

Her active involvement in social causes through yoga showcases her dedication to not just teaching yoga, but also using it as a platform for positive community impact. Ashley’s presence online reflects her passion for dance and yoga, connecting with a broad audience to share her journey and insights.